[.ca] Five Little Pigs (ISBN 0425093255)

caught me all thru the night:
when an unsolved murder that happened 15 yrs ago,you just couldnt expect other people cracking the mystery and pinpoint the particular murderer after so many years have passed...but in this book...it happens.hercule poirot,using his 'little grey cells' trying to discover the murderer in an ingenious way...you can expect good mystery from this book

Well-written but not my most favorite Christie book:
When Caroline Crale is accused for the murder of her husband, Amyas Crale, no one supposes that she could be in any way innocent. After Mrs. Crale dies only one year after being tried and convicted, the murder is laid to rest. But now 16 years later, the Crale daughter, Carla, is given a letter from her mother. Mrs. Crale had written the letter before her death, in which she explicitly says she wasn't guilty of murder. Now Carla is determined to know the truth and hires the best person for the job, the remarkable Hercule Poirot. But can Poirot solve a murder which took place 16 years before? Agatha Christie certainly spins a terrific story revolving around a murder which has been laid to rest for 16 years. Throughout the story we are given different points of views from different characters. This novel truly defines the meaning of 'in the eye of the beholder' since everyone has a different account to tell, a different viewpoint, and a difference in remembering facts. Though Poirot will never have the chance to meet the victim (Amyas Crale) or the supposed murderess (Caroline Crale), with the help of interviewing the people involved long ago. Part One tells about Poirot's interviews with the counsel for the defence, counsel for the prosecution, the solicitors, the police superintendent, and the five witnesses. Then Book Two focuses on the narratives of the five witnesses and the conclusion to the story. Here's a quick introduction to the five witnesses (and suspects!). The title, "Five Little Pigs", refers to these five characters; Philip Blake - went to market: Best friend to the murdered victim, has good business sense and is a very precise man. Could he have devised the perfect plan to kill? Meredith Blake - stayed at home: The perfect example of a English country gentleman. Loves nature and has a very quiet temperament, but could he actually be a murderer? Elsa Greer - ate roast beef. She falls in love with Amyas and finds nothing wrong with stealing him from a lovely wife and daughter. Extremely greedy and selfish, could she kill her lover? Miss William - got none. A governess in the Crale household, she was soon going to be dismissed from teaching Mrs. Crale's young sister. Also has a distaste for men, and was angry at Amywas for wanting to leave his wife. Angela Warren - cried all the way home. Disfigured sister of Mrs. Crale, had many fights and arguments with the murdered man. Everyone has a motive, and everyone seems to be hiding something. Who is the murderer and what had exactly taken place on that fateful day of Amyas' death? After reading to almost the conclusion, you'll probably have an idea what had happened. But I most assure, Christie has plenty of surprises and twists and turns for you! "Five Little Pigs" is certainly well-written and should not be missed, but it's not one of my most favorite Christie stories. And some people might find it a bit repetitive though that's the beauty of the whole story, how everything meshes together subtly. I recommend you read "The Mysterious Affair at Styles" if you have never read any of Agatha Christie's mysteries before.

The one that I enjoyed the most so far:
For many years I didn't read any of Agatha's books, deceived by the unspoken prejudice against all writers of mystery novels, that somehow they're not "real" writers, as if they stood to literature like entertainers stand to "genuine", quality artists and performers. I liked some of the adaptations I saw of her works though, and always had a soft spot for "Murder on the Orient Express" so I finally gave in and became a fan, especially of Hercule Poirot. I didn't think her work could bring me any more surprises, so many books later. So I was delighted at how much I loved this one. It has all the characteristics that have made her dear to me, especially as an author, for these things are sometimes nowhere to be found in adaptations one sees: characters who are basically mouthpieces to Agatha's views on the world and life; the way Poirot's ridiculousness makes him so easily underestimated by friends and foes alike; and in Agatha's mysteries the crime and whodunit is merely a pretext to watch and observe and reflect upon people whom you become more and more fascinated with, sometimes just because you're watching. It's like Hitchcock's "Rear Window", but some decades earlier. I even fell into the trap of thinking that this time I had guessed correctly who the killer was, something I never do. What for? Agatha always beats me, and this time was no exception. I particularly loved the ending, the best I have ever read in any mystery novel and, to me, eerily reminiscent of Conan Doyle's "The Blue Carbuncle". For those who feel curious, the painting that is described as a blind girl sitting on an orange is by George Frederic Watts and is called Hope because the harp she's holding has only one string left but she doesn't give up playing upon it.

Incredibly effective:
This is a simple story. A bit like Cards on the Table, there is a relatively small scope of suspects. (In Cards... there were fourl. this one there are five.) All of them are interesting and well developed, and all of them COULD have done it. But did any of them have a motive? This is one of Christie's best Poirot stories...Poirot goes back into the past to investigate a sixteen year old murder. the culprit was caught, and died soon after in prison. But years later, someone is determined to prove that they were innoncent...Which means, someone else is still guilty. Poirot has to learn about all the events which went on 16 years ago through a distorted lens. Time has muddied the waters, and people's reccolections are sometimes very acute...but some are also very hazy. Having been convinced of the guilt of Caroline Crale, they have since shaped their view of events around that belief. He delves effectively into the past. We meet up with the characters again, and Christie develops them all very well. She uses some very original and interesting narrative devices, and the reader truly does have exactly the same opportunities as Poirot to solve the crime. The solution is suitably clever...and even though there are so few suspects, the reader is STILL surprised by the culprit!

A first-rate example of Agatha Christie's virtuosity:
Not often the American title of an Agatha Christie novel is an improvement to the original one, but this is truly an exception: "Murder in Retrospect" nicely catches the basic idea of the novel, whereas the original title "Five Little Pigs" is somewhat tacky and might set you off on the wrong foot. No, this book is not about a serial killer using a nursery rhyme as the blueprint for his crimes. It's all about the past. When Carla Lemarchant asks the great Hercule Poirot for help, she isn't referring to a crime of which the body is still warm, but talks about a murder that has taken place 16 years ago. Carla's mother was found to be the guilty party and as a result she found her death in prison, taking the truth with her to the grave. But just before her death she managed to write a short letter to her daughter saying that she was not guilty. Now Carla wants Poirot to dive into the past in a search for the truth. Undoubtedly Agatha Christie was in great form when she started plotting this intriguing mystery. Not only did she create a stunning story line, she also added some 'remarkably' rich characterizations. Remarkably because regular readers of her oeuvre may remark that character development is surely not one of her strongest points. Even more reasons to call this work a piece of 'literature'. Quite remarkably is the structure used to communicate to the reader all the information about this murder. The five main characters -five little pigs- write down each their own version of the facts. If read very carefully, comparing these versions can bring the reader very close to the final solution. But don't be to euphoric when you think to have solved the crime: Agatha Christie surely has some surprises in stock for you. Certainly in this must-read mystery novel!