Emma (Barnes & Noble Classics) (ISBN 1593083343)

Didn't like the paper quality and presentation:
I bought them (all the Barnes & Noble Classics) to complete my Jane Austen's collection, and honestly, didn't like the paper quality, it seems like they didn't even care for the presentation of them; it didn't look elegant, cheap to be more specific.

Excellent!:
Emma Woodhouse is an atypical heroine for a Jane Austen novel. Usually, we see disadvantaged girls struggle to find happiness through marriage. In Emma's case, we see a girl who has everything in the world she could want. She is rich, pretty, and happy. She has no desire to be married, as it would interfere with the simple life she enjoys with her father and she knows it would break his heart to be parted from her. The story follows Emma's life beginning at 21 as she tries to help a young girl named Harriet Smith marry above her station. Emma also engages in a flirtation with a young man and generally makes a bit of a mess of things whenever she gets involved. I have read that Jane Austen felt that Emma was a character only her creator could like. I would have to disagree with that. Emma is certainly flawed, but her heart is almost always in the right place. Pride has blinded her to her own limitations but she is also one who does not shrink from the responsibility of her mistakes and tries very hard to learn from them. I found this admirable and grew to like her more and more as the book progressed. Aside from Emma, the rest of the cast was also very well written. Her father is a complete hypochondriac and often engages in behavior that would typically be considered highly rude. Yet, he is motivated so completely by a desire to be kind to others that his misguided application of that desire only endears him to the reader. Mr. Knightley, the no-nonsense friend of the family is admittedly not the most complex character in the world, but he is a very good one and his solidity is a great counterbalance to Emma's wishful thinking. In summary, Emma is a nice change of pace from Jane Austen's other novels. It starts off well and grows more engaging as it continues. The characters are interesting and Emma herself grows considerably during the course of the novel.

Buy a Different Edition:
I love Jane Austen's stories so my problem is not with them at all - the physical book, however, was awful. The pages are that of books from a book club. The paper was coarse and had uneven edges. The information in the book was great, including other movies and books inspired by each novel. I really like that part of it but could not get over the lack of quality in the paper and presentation. Unless you do not mind the eyesores and absent neatness, buy a different version of this book.

Poor Condition:
This book is VERY poor condition. The pages are uneven and look like they were cut when the blade needed changing or sharpening or cut with too many at once. I am returning it to Amazon, the only good thing is that I bought it with Amazon, they are paying for return shipping. I have to say that I am very pleased with Amazon's CS. I am a frequent customer and will continue to be.

A sturdy edition and a value buy:
Frankly I am puzzled by the criticisms leveled at this edition. There is another edition (also by Barnes and Noble) and it is cheaper, though the quality is very flimsy and I wonder if the other reviewers were confused with that edition? This edition of Emma is beautifully bound, with a cloth spine, and has a lovely portrait on the cover. The text is not too small unlike some other editions, it makes for comfortable reading. The book itself is sturdy, as it is in hardback, but not unwieldy - it fits nicely into my hands. Besides the main text of Austen's novel itself, it has added features - a brief chronology of the world of Jane Austen & Emma, an introduction, the main text, as well as useful endnotes, a list of adaptations of the novel (in both film and book format),comments, as well as a list of resources for further reading (biographies and letters of Austen) and criticisms. In all, a value buy.